Review by Jon Donnis
Guillermo del Toro's 2025 take on Frankenstein feels like a filmmaker pouring his heart into a story he has cherished for years. It shows from the opening moments on the icebound Horisont Navy Ship. The film settles into a confident stride straight away, using the familiar framing of Victor recounting his sins while the shadow of his creation closes in. It taps into the soul of Mary Shelley's novel with a level of devotion that never feels stiff. Instead it feels lived in, tender in places, and achingly sad in others.
Oscar Isaac gives Victor a cold brilliance that suits the character's inflated sense of purpose. His fall from promising surgeon to broken fugitive has real weight, helped by the film's astonishing design work at every stage. Del Toro fills each frame with towering sets, rich colour, and the sort of textured detail that makes even the bleakest landscape feel strangely inviting. The world around Victor and the Creature has an almost painterly glow. It feels crafted by someone who understands the gothic tone down to its bone marrow. When the story shifts to the Creature's memories, the change in mood is gentle but striking. The forest scenes, the warmth of the blind man's home, the eerie calm of the Arctic. Everything is lit and staged with a confidence that reminds you why del Toro has long been considered a master of monsters.
Jacob Elordi's version of the Creature is one of the film's strongest elements. He captures the pain, confusion, and flickers of fragile hope that define the character. His scenes of learning and companionship are some of the film's most affecting. The only drawback is physical. Elordi plays the emotional notes beautifully, yet he never quite looks as imposing as the classic image of Frankenstein's creation. It is a small gripe, though it does stand out when the story leans into the Creature's terrifying strength.
The length will also test some viewers. At around two and a half hours the film never feels slow, yet it is still a solid commitment. The emotional heft piles up steadily. By the time Victor and the Creature meet again in the present, you can feel the journey in your chest. Their final moment together is quiet, painful, and beautifully earned.
What impresses most is how del Toro reshapes a tale we all know without distorting its essence. This is still a story about life, death, grief, and responsibility. It simply tilts the focus a little more toward forgiveness. Personally, I found myself missing a touch more of the Creature's rage, something closer to the fury of Shelley's original. Even so, it is hard not to admire the sincerity behind this version. It is crafted with love and it shows.
In the wider landscape of adaptations, this may be the finest screen telling so far. It looks extraordinary, it feels deeply human, and it marks a strong return to form for del Toro. I walked away convinced he was born to make this film.
A confident and resonant triumph, and an easy 9 out of 10.
Out Now on Netflix - https://www.netflix.com/gb/title/81507921
And in Select Cinemas










